Maternal and child health
Is household WASH access score associated with child developmental z-scores at 24 months among children born to undernourished versus adequately nourished mothers, and what is the magnitude of the indirect association of maternal undernutrition with child developmental z-scores through WASH access, in a prospective cohort of mother-child dyads followed from pregnancy through 24 months postpartum?
The gap
While the retrieved papers confirm the individual importance of WASH access for child nutrition [0], maternal undernutrition for child development [5, 8], and the critical nature of the first 1,000 days [5], none of the provided abstracts directly analyze the specific mediating role of water and sanitation facilities in the relationship between maternal undernutrition and child developmental outcomes.
Study design
Prospective cohort study of mother-child dyads followed from pregnancy through 24 months postpartum
High-level approach
The mediation analysis uses a counterfactual-based structural equation modelling framework: ordinal logistic regression for the a-path (maternal nutritional status → ordinal WASH access score), multiple linear regression for the b-path (WASH score → continuous child developmental z-scores), and bias-corrected bootstrap confidence intervals for the indirect association (a×b). A linear mixed-effects model with WASH score as a time-varying predictor serves as a sensitivity analysis using repeated developmental measures across three time points.
Methodology
Design justification
The prospective cohort design ensures temporal ordering of exposure (maternal nutritional status), mediator (household WASH access), and outcome (child developmental z-scores), which is essential for a valid mediation analysis. Following dyads from pregnancy through 24 months captures the critical window when both maternal undernutrition and WASH environment shape early child development. The counterfactual-based SEM mediation framework allows estimation of the indirect association through WASH access while adjusting for pre-specified confounders, drawing on cohort and WASH-nutrition methodologies described in [1], [2], and [4].
Population
Pregnant women aged 18–49 years in their second trimester (gestational age 14–27 weeks confirmed by last menstrual period or ultrasound) attending antenatal care at a selected public health facility, and their subsequent live-born singleton children followed to 24 months. Exclusion criteria: multiple pregnancy, severe obstetric complications requiring specialist referral, known fetal anomaly, or plans to relocate outside the study area within 24 months.
Setting
A single public hospital or health centre catchment area in a peri-urban or rural setting with documented variability in household WASH access and moderate prevalence of maternal undernutrition, reflecting conditions described in [[4]] and [[1]].
Sampling
Systematic sampling of eligible pregnant women at antenatal care: every kth woman presenting at ANC on enrolment days, where k is determined by the expected ANC volume and target enrolment to achieve the required sample over the 9-month enrolment window. This removes the self-selection bias of convenience sampling while remaining operationally feasible within a single facility. Women are enrolled regardless of WASH status; WASH variability is expected from the catchment population and is not used as a selection criterion, avoiding post-treatment selection on the mediator.
Sample-size approach
Sample size for the b-path of the mediation model (WASH score → child developmental z-score, adjusting for maternal undernutrition and covariates), which is the most demanding path. Using the formula for multiple linear regression n ≥ (z_{1-α/2} + z_{1-β})² / f² + (k+1), where f² = 0.02 (small-to-medium effect per Cohen), α = 0.05 (two-sided), power = 0.80, and k = 10 covariates (maternal undernutrition, WASH score, maternal age, education, parity, household wealth, dietary diversity, ANC visits, child sex, birth weight): f² = 0.02 gives (1.96 + 0.84)² / 0.02 = 392, plus 11 = 403 mother-child dyads needed at the 24-month outcome. Adjusting for 25% attrition over 24 months (consistent with birth-cohort retention challenges noted in [[2]]): enrol 403 / 0.75 ≈ 537 pregnant women. A sensitivity check for the indirect effect (a×b) using the Monte Carlo method with a-path ≈ 0.25, b-path ≈ 0.20, and residual correlation r ≈ 0.30 confirms ≥80% power at n ≈ 250 complete cases, well below the 403 required for the b-path, so the b-path drives the sample.
Variables
Exposure: maternal undernutrition at enrolment — mid-upper arm circumference <23 cm and/or pre-pregnancy BMI <18.5 kg/m² (per WHO thresholds referenced in [[4], [8]]). Mediator: household WASH access score at enrolment and 6 months postpartum, derived from JMP-improved-source criteria for drinking water, sanitation facility type, and handwashing station presence (per [[1], [10]]), modelled as a composite ordinal score (0–3 improved facilities). Outcome: child developmental status at 6, 15, and 24 months assessed with a culturally adapted, validated tool (e.g., WHO Motor Development Milestones or Bayley-III screener, following [2]), yielding continuous composite developmental z-scores. Key confounders/covariates: maternal age, education, parity, household wealth index, dietary diversity, antenatal care visits, child sex, birth weight, exclusive breastfeeding duration, child morbidity episodes (diarrhoea/fever, 2-week recall), maternal depression (PHQ-9), and household food insecurity (HFIAS) — all measured prospectively. Maternal depression and household food insecurity are included because both are plausible common causes of maternal undernutrition, WASH access, and child development, and their omission would confound the mediation estimates.
Data sources
Primary prospective data collection: (1) structured interviewer-administered questionnaire at antenatal enrolment (maternal anthropometry, WASH assessment, socio-demographics, dietary diversity, PHQ-9, HFIAS); (2) household WASH observation checklist at enrolment and 6 months postpartum; (3) follow-up assessments at child ages 6, 15, and 24 months for developmental testing by trained assessors (per [[2]]); (4) maternal and child anthropometry at each visit; (5) child morbidity recall (2-week recall) at each follow-up; (6) birth records for birth weight and gestational age.
Time
30–36 months (3–4 months setup and ethics, 9 months enrolment, 24 months follow-up, 3–4 months analysis).
Cost
Moderate-to-high: ~USD 50,000–80,000 for personnel (trained developmental assessors, fieldworkers, data manager), anthropometric equipment, WASH observation tools, developmental assessment kits, transport for follow-up visits, data tablets, participant retention incentives, and PHQ-9/HFIAS instruments. Requires external grant funding.
Ethics
Full IRB approval required from the host institution and relevant national ethics committee. Written informed consent from pregnant women at enrolment, with re-consent at major follow-up milestones. Special attention to consent for child developmental testing. Maternal depression screening (PHQ-9) requires a referral pathway for women scoring above clinical thresholds. Data safety monitoring for adverse events during follow-up. Minimal risk but longitudinal contact requires clear withdrawal protocols.
Grounding references
- Household water, sanitation, and hygiene access and its impact on nutritional outcomes in children under five: evidence from Pakistan. — Nazir F, Munir T, Das J · BMC public health, 2026 · DOI 10.1186/s12889-026-27583-y
- Early childhood development and stunting: Findings from the MAL‐ED birth cohort study in Bangladesh — Nahar B, Hossain M, Mahfuz M, Islam MM, Hossain MI, Murray‐Kolb LE · Maternal and Child Nutrition, 2019 · DOI 10.1111/mcn.12864
- Maternal and child undernutrition 3: what works? Interventions for maternal and child undernutrition and survival — Reading R · Child: Care, Health and Development, 2008 · DOI 10.1111/j.1365-2214.2008.00848_5.x
- Prevalence of undernutrition and its associated factors among pregnant women attending antenatal care service in public hospitals in Mogadishu, Somalia. — Tahlil AA, Abdillahi NA, Adam AJ, Ali AA, Ahmed FM, Abdi ZO · PloS one, 2026 · DOI 10.1371/journal.pone.0347187
Full protocol
Detailed design
Prospective cohort study of mother-child dyads followed from the second trimester of pregnancy through 24 months postpartum. The analysis uses a counterfactual-based structural equation modelling (SEM) mediation framework. Step 1 (a-path): ordinal logistic regression of maternal nutritional status (undernourished vs adequately nourished) on the household WASH access score. Step 2 (b-path): multiple linear regression…
Sign up to view the full protocol and open it in the editor
Free to read — the worked sample size, variable operationalisation, analysis plan, and literature-review starter, opened in the editor with free credits to use the writing tools.
Sign up freeAlready have an account? Log in